My dad checked this book out from the library when I was probably six, read it in one sitting, and made me swear that I would never, ever read "that dreadful, dreadful book". Now, my dad has never been very good at forbidding me to do things, and I've never been very good at obeying orders, so you can probably see where this went. When he checked it in, I grabbed it off the "to-be-shelved" rack and read it, right there in the library. And now, almost ten years later, I read it again.
My dad was right - Black-Eyed Suzie, by Susan Shaw, really isn't appropriate for a six year old. That being said, I would recommend it to practically everyone else. The narration is full of personality, and the characters (a few of them, at least), are developed surprisingly well for such a short little book. Suzie is a dark-eyed twelve year old whose only job is to sit on her golden chair, knees tucked up to her chest - silent. It's how she avoids her mother's abuse and her father's neglect. But when Uncle Elliott comes for a visit, Suzie and her family are in for some big changes ... Always touching but sometimes aggravatingly overdone, it's a highly original take on domestic violence and a child's need for love. It ends perfectly, with a few loose endings - but that's life. Very nice book.
My dad was right - Black-Eyed Suzie, by Susan Shaw, really isn't appropriate for a six year old. That being said, I would recommend it to practically everyone else. The narration is full of personality, and the characters (a few of them, at least), are developed surprisingly well for such a short little book. Suzie is a dark-eyed twelve year old whose only job is to sit on her golden chair, knees tucked up to her chest - silent. It's how she avoids her mother's abuse and her father's neglect. But when Uncle Elliott comes for a visit, Suzie and her family are in for some big changes ... Always touching but sometimes aggravatingly overdone, it's a highly original take on domestic violence and a child's need for love. It ends perfectly, with a few loose endings - but that's life. Very nice book.
Hungry Lionel gives this:
3.5/5

